Okay..so it's not completely home-made but near enough and it's rediculously SIMPLE!!
All you need is one bottle of SUKIN Hydrating Mist Toner (available at Farmers/Chemists) and some Sweet Almond Oil or Jojoba Oil. Both these oils have wonderful vitamins for your skin to absorb.
In a dark bottle mix 1 part oil to 2 parts Sukin Toner and shake before use. Wipe on with a cotton make-up pad over the eye, then wipe off. Yip... that's it! It's what I use and it feels good on the skin unlike other alcohol based removers which tend to dry out the skin and irritate the sensitive eye area.
The Sukin Toner is made of rosewater and chamomile, sounds good right.. and it is!!??
Give it a try and see what you think!